Plans for a retirement community in Comberton were rejected due to concerns about creating a ‘senior ghetto’ and strain on local services.
The developers wanted to build 200 care units and other facilities. They argued it would meet a big need for older housing. But many locals disagreed.
Concerns were raised about access to services. The GP surgery said they were already at capacity. They feared adding more seniors would strain resources.
Ellen Pearce, the developer’s rep, insisted there’s a real need for this type of housing. She mentioned limited options for older folks in the area.
She also pointed out that they’d invest over £2 million into the community. But objections kept piling up from residents and local officials.
Councillor Jessica Marshall echoed worries about the GP surgery. She also criticized the design, calling it too urban for the village.
Another local, Claire Michel, raised issues about the sewage system. She feared it couldn’t handle the extra load. The developer claimed Anglian Water said it was fine.
Councillor Heather Williams noted the many objections. She agreed there’s a need for supported housing but said it should be spread out.
Councillor Peter Sandford emphasized that Comberton’s population is already high in seniors. Adding more could create a “senior ghetto.”
He pointed out the village’s limited transport and services. He argued this development was inappropriate for the area.
Councillor Anna Bradnam and Dr. Martin Cahn also supported spreading housing across the district. They felt the proposed site was too isolated.
Dr. Tumi Hawkins raised concerns about the health needs of future residents. She said the proposed clinical space wouldn’t be enough.
In the end, the councillors voted unanimously to reject the application.
